Menus
Order Now
Lunch
Monday-Friday 11:00 AM-2:00 PM
Slices and Pre-Ordered Whole Pies*
*Avoid the wait order whole pies online or by phone
Dinner
Thursday, Friday & Saturday 5:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Slices and Whole Pies – DELIVERY & PICK-UP ONLY, DINING ROOM CLOSED
New Haven Tomato
Thin crust, tomato Sauce, Pecorino Romano Cheese-
Slice
$5.50
-
Whole Pie
$17
Cheese Pie
Thin Crust, Tomato Sauce, Pecorino Romano & Mozzarella-
Slice
$6
-
Whole Pie
$18
Pepperoni Pie
Thin Crust, Tomato Sauce, Pepperoni, Pecorino Romano & Mozzarella-
Slice
$6
-
Whole Pie
$20
Sausage Pie
Sweet Italian Sausage, Tomato Sauce, Pecorino Romano & Mozzarella-
Slice
$6
-
Whoel Pie
$20
Pepperoni & Sausage Pie
Pepperoni, Sweet Italian Sausage, Tomato Sauce, Pecorino Romano & Mozzarella-
Slcie
$6.50
-
Whoel Pie
$22
Bagels
-
Half Dozen
$10
-
Dozen
$18
Less than a half dozen, each $2
-
Flavors
Plain, Sesame, Poppyseed, Onion, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg & Sea Salt, Pumpernickel, Everything
-
“the Skinny Gussy” Any Bagel Flavor – Half the Carbs!
Bagels & Lox
-
Any Bagel
Any Schmear
Choice of Salmon
-
Flavors
Gravlax - Dill & Citrus Cured
Pastrami Lox - Cold-Smoked Salmon Rubbed
with Gussy’s Famous Pastrami Mix
-
Add-Ons
Tomato, Onion, Capers
$14
Schmear Flavors
-
Plain, Caper, Wild Berry, Honey Walnut, Scallion, Chocolate Hazelnut, Garden Veggie
Sandwich $4.50
Half-Pound $7
-
Avocado, Bacon-Pimento
Sandwich $6
Half-Pound $10
-
Smoked Whitefish, Smoked Salmon
Sandwich $9
Half-Pound $12
-
Pre-order Dozen + Bagel Flavors
Sandwiches
-
Big Gussy
Triple-Layer Old World Rye, Pastrami, Corned Beef, White American, Horseradish, Red Onion, Pickle, Gussy’s Famous Sauce
$18
-
Da Malppy
Pastrami, Red Onion, White American, Lettuce, Tomato, Italian Dressing, Soft Italian Bread
$14
-
Big Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Italian Vinaigrette, Everything Bagel
$14
-
Slyly Rye-ly
Shaved Turkey, Cheddar, Coleslaw, Pickle, Gussy’s Famous Sauce, Pumpernickel Bagel
$14
-
I’m All-Yinz
Buffalo Chicken Salad, Bacon, Pepper Jack, Coleslaw, Pickle, Soft Italian Bread
$14
-
Robin “Who’s Rachel?”
Turkey Pastrami, Swiss, Coleslaw, Horseradish, Gussy’s Famous Sauce, Marble Rye
$15
-
Big Liz-Bowski
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, White American, Tomato, Mayo, Soft Italian Bread
$14
-
MWM Grand
Corned Beef, Cole Slaw, Horseradish, Swiss, Pickle, Gussy’s Famous Sauce, Marble Rye
$14
Build Your Own Sandwich
-
Choice of Bagel or Bread
Italian, Marble Rye, Traditional Rye, Wheat
-
Choice of Meat or Salad
Corned Beef $12
Pastrami $12
Oven Roasted Turkey $10
Turkey Pastrami $10
White Albacore Tuna Salad $10
Amish Chicken Salad $10
Buffalo Ranch Amish Chicken Salad $10
Includes a Kosher Dill
-
Choice of Cheese
White American, Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack
-
Veggie Options
Lettuce, Onions, Tomato, Cole Slaw, Sliced Pickles, Capers, Avocado
-
Dressing/Sauce
Mayo, Brown Mustard, Horseradish Mustard, Buffalo Ranch, Gussy’s Famous Sauce
-
Get It “Gussied Up”
Mix and Match Any 2 Meats, Cole Slaw, Shaved Red Onion, Your Choice of Cheese, Gussy’s Famous Sauce
$16
Breakfast Sandwiches
-
Top Gunnar
Bacon, Sausage, Egg, Cheddar Cheese, Gussy’s Famous Sauce, Sesame Bagel
$9
-
Smiling Sarah
Bacon, Egg, White American, Hash brown, Maple Sauce, Plain Bagel
$9
-
Big Bootch
Corned Beef, Egg, Swiss, Hash brown, Gussy’s Famous Sauce, Pumpernickel Bagel
$9
-
Gussy’s Famous Sauce
$0.50
Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich
-
Any Bagel, 2 Eggs
Choice of Meat: Bacon or Sausage
Choice of Cheese: White American, Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack $7
-
Add-Ons
Taylor Ham, Pastrami, Corn Beef, Hash brown
$1
-
Get It “Gussied Up”
Choice of Bagel, Meat & Cheese with A Hash brown and Gussy’s Famous Sauce
$8
Soup
-
Gussy’s Famous Chicken Noodle Soup
Amish Chicken, Carrots, Celery, Onion, Dumpling-Noodles
Cup $4
Bowl $6
Quart $12
Drinks
-
KLVN Coffee
Small $2
Large $4
-
KLVN Iced Coffee
$4
-
Sodas & Water
$2
-
Gussy’s Old Fashioned Lemonade
$5
Sides
-
Chips “Uglies”
Kettle-Cooked Pennsylvania Chips Flavors: Original, Sea Salt Vinegar, Barbecue, Buffalo Ranch, Jalapeño
Bag $2
-
Coleslaw
Quarter-Pound $3
-
GUSSY’S EVERYTHING COOKIE
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Coated in Gussy's Sweet Everything Spice; Walnut, Sesame, Poppy, Cinnamon, Sea Salt
Each $3
Dozen $30
-
Mille’s Ice Cream
Pint $8
Scoop $4
Deli
-
Pastrami & Corned Beef
One Pound $20
Half-Pound $10
Quarter-Pound $5
-
Turkey Pastrami & Oven Roasted Turkey
One Pound $12
Half-Pound $6
Quarter-Pound $3
-
Gravlax – Dill Citrus Cured Salmon
One Pound $36
Half-Pound $18
Quarter-Pound $9
-
Pastrami Lox -Cold-Smoked Salmon Rubbed with Gussy’s Famous Pastrami Mix
One Pound $36
Half-Pound $18
Quarter-Pound $9
-
Whitefish & Smoked Salmon Spreads
One Pound $24
Half-Pound $12
Quarter-Pound $6
-
Albacore Tuna Salad
One Pound $12
Half-Pound $6
-
Amish Chicken Salad
One Pound $14
Half-Pound $7
-
Amish Buffalo Chicken Salad
One Pound $16
Half-Pound $8
-
Gussy’s Big Chocolate Chip Everything Cookie
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Coated in Gussy's Sweet Everything Spice; Walnut, Sesame, Poppy, Cinnamon, Sea Salt
Each $3
Per Dozen $30
-
Gussy’s Famous Sauce
8 ounces $12
Breakfast Box
$10 per person-
Full Sandwiches Cut & Individually Wrapped on Your Choice of Bagels
-
Egg, Bacon, Cheddar
-
Sausage, Egg, American Cheese
-
Egg, Cheese, Avocado, Tomato
-
Gussie It Up with Hash Browns and Corned Beef or Pastrami with Gussy’s Famous Sauce
$2
Lunch Box
$20 per person-
Full Sandwiches Cut & Individually Wrapped, Uglies Chips, and a Gussy’s Everything Cookie
-
Big Liz-Bowksi
Oven Roasted Turkey, Bacon, White American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato on Toasted Italian White Bread, Plain or Everything Bagel
-
The Malppy
Pastrami, Red Onion, White American, Lettuce, Tomato, Italian Dressing, Soft Italian Bread, Plain or Everything Bagel
-
MWM Grand
Corned Beef, Cole Slaw, Horseradish, Swiss, Pickle, Gussy’s Famous Sauce on Marble Rye, Plain or Everything Bagel
-
Big Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Italian Vinaigrette on Toasted White Italian Bread, Plain or Everything Bagel
DRINKS
-
Gallon KLVN Coffee Box
One Gallon $25
-
Gallon Gussy's Famous Lemonade Box
$25
-
Juice
Each $3
-
Soda
Each $3
-
Water
Each $2
SIDES
-
Coleslaw
One Pound $12
Half-Pound $6
Quarter-Pound $3
-
Uglies Chips Variety of Flavors
Each $2
-
Kosher Dill Pickles
Each $1
-
Millie’s Ice Cream
Pint $8
Scoop $4
Dessert
-
Gussy’s Everything Cookie
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Coated in Gussy's Sweet Everything Spice; Walnut, Sesame, Poppy, Cinnamon, Sea Salt
Per Dozen $30
Lox Box
$16 per person-
Full Sandwiches Cut & Wrapped Individually on Your Choice of Bagels with House Cured Lox
-
Tomato Caper and Onion or Plain Schmear
Bagel Box with Schmears
$32 per Dozen-
A Dozen of Your Choice of Fresh Baked Bagels with Your Choice of 2 (Half-Pound) Schmears
-
Plain, Egg & Sea Salt, Everything, Sesame, Poppyseed, Pumpernickel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagels
-
Plain, Caper, Scallion, Garden Veggie, Wild Berry, Bacon Pimento, Chocolate Hazelnut, Honey Walnut Schmears
-
Additions
Smoked Whitefish, Smoked Salmon Half-Pound
$12
Delicatessen Build Your Own Sandwich Tray
$18 per person-
Choose 3
Turkey, Turkey Pastrami, Corned Beef, Amish Chicken Salad, Buffalo Chicken Salad
-
Choose 3
White American, Swiss, Cheddar, Pepper Jack
-
Choice of Breads
Plain or Everything Bagels, Marble Rye or Italian Soft
-
Includes: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Brown Mustard, Mayo, Gussie Sauce